Unlock $1.45 Billion: The ESOP Advantage
Are ESOPs really worth it?
Here's something to pique your interest: Indian startup employees have made $1.45 billion through ESOPs since 2020.
Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs) have become a cornerstone of employee benefits and compensation in many Indian startups, yet the technicalities can still be confusing, especially for newcomers. So that you don’t have to spend hours reading countless articles on ESOP taxation and regulations, we at MetaMorph meticulously crafted the ESOPs 101 report, that breaks it all down for you. Whether you’re an employer or an employee, this guide will help demystify the world of ESOPs.
In this week’s newsletter:
ESOPs Unwrapped: Dive into the basics of ESOPs and why they matter.
Ready or Not: Signs your startup is set for an ESOP plan.
MetaMorph’s extensive ESOPs 101 Report.
Expert Take: A Q&A with Varun Rajda, Founding Partner at Constellation Blu.
ESOPs Unwrapped
In the last decade, ESOPs have become a go-to for many Indian startups for employee retention. Flipkart was a pioneer in the use of ESOPs in India, granting stock options to 700 employees as early as 2009. This strategy was instrumental in attracting and retaining talent during its formative years, ultimately helping Flipkart emerge as India's leading e-commerce platform. Now-giants like Paytm, Ola, Zomato, Swiggy followed - offering ESOPs to not just senior executives, but also junior employees.
Swiggy recently marked its 10th Anniversary by unveiling its fifth ESOPs buyback program worth $65 million - as it prepares for an IPO and navigates a competitive market. This would be their fifth liquidity event since 2018, and third consecutive event after July 2022 and 2023. The company has cumulatively enabled over Rs 1000 Cr of ESOPs liquidity over the five events, benefitting over 3200 employees. This has clearly benefitted the startup too, as it is on course to report over 20% uptick in revenue in FY24, from the INR 8,260 Cr it reported in FY23, as per INC42.
An Employee Stock Option Plan or ESOP is a program that gives employees the option to buy shares of their company at a fixed price. After a particular waiting time, employees can buy the shares at a special price, which is usually lower than the current price of the shares in the market. Here’s a simple breakdown of how they work:
ESOPs give employees a sense of ownership in the company, and it’s great compensation for them beyond salaries and other benefits. ESOPs not only offer financial benefits but also contribute to a positive workplace culture where employees are invested in the company's success and growth. If the company does well, the value of the shares can go up, meaning employees can make a lot of money by selling their shares at a higher price than they paid for them.
But how do they help startups?
ESOPs comes with its own set of challenges, from a lack of clarity in regulations to taxation complexities. One of the biggest drawbacks is the lack of liquidity; employees often must wait for IPOs or acquisitions to cash out, events less frequent here than in the US. This makes ESOPs less attractive for employees who may have to wait many years to liquidate their shares. This is where ESOP buybacks come in. ESOP buyback is a liquidity event for qualified employees, which allows them to sell shares they hold back to the company. This is what Swiggy is in the news for right now — they are repurchasing unexercised options at a nominal value and giving cash consideration as a bonus. Buybacks provide a way for employees to monetise their shares, offering financial returns without waiting for a public offering or sale of the company.
Ready or Not: How do you know your startup is ready for ESOPs?
While ESOP plans vary widely, a common recommendation is to introduce them between the pre-seed and early-stage venture capital phases of a startup's growth. Steve Parr in this Youtube Video explains that ESOPs are generally useful for startups after “a first round of financing has been done but before it has begun doing a major round of hiring”
As per this article, many early-stage startups allocate an ESOP pool, usually around 10% of their total shares. Over the first two to four years of operation, they use these stock options to attract and retain talent who might not otherwise be inclined to join the company. As startups navigate these crucial stages, implementing ESOPs can significantly improve their chances to compete for top talent and sustain momentum towards achieving their long-term objectives.
ESOPs 101: Turning Job Offers into Wealth Opportunities
There is a lot more to ESOPs than what can be covered in an email newsletter - which is why MetaMorph’s Research & Consulting Team put months of research and meticulously crafted the ESOPs 101 guide.
Here's what you'll gain from our in-depth ESOP report:
Founders & HR: Explore ESOPs as a strategic tool for attracting top talent, aligning employee interests with long-term success, and fostering a culture of ownership.
VCs: Gain insights into how ESOPs can impact a startup's talent strategy, retention rates, and overall growth potential during investment evaluations.
Employees: Demystify the world of ESOPs, understand vesting periods, navigate tax implications, and unlock the wealth-creation potential associated with stock options.
Expert Take: A Q&A with Varun Rajda, Founding Partner at Constellation Blu
In this exclusive Q&A session with Varun Rajda, we delve into crucial insights regarding the strategic implications of ESOPs for startups. Varun shares his expertise on evaluating offers from an employee's perspective, strategic considerations for founders in designing ESOP pools, and the impact of ESOPs on financial statements and fundraising efforts. His perspectives shed light on navigating complexities and leveraging ESOPs effectively to foster growth and incentivise talent at different stages of a startup's journey.
How can employees best evaluate an ESOP offer in a startup? What factors should they consider besides the number of options granted?
Employees should evaluate ESOP offers by considering factors like strike price, vesting period, and last round FMV. They need to understand how many ESOPs they're receiving and what that translates into in terms of monetary value. The strike price is crucial because it affects the net benefit—the FMV minus the strike price should ideally cover what you're sacrificing in cash compensation. For instance, if you expect a 50 lakh compensation but receive 35 lakhs in cash, you should aim for at least 15 lakhs in ESOPs on a net basis. This compensates for the non-cash nature of ESOPs and the potential growth they offer. Additionally, consider the company's type, growth trajectory, and other contextual factors beyond just personal considerations.
For startup founders, what are the strategic considerations when designing an ESOP pool? How can the size of the pool, vesting schedules, and exercise prices be used to incentivize different employee groups and stages of growth?
Founders should manage their ESOP pool judiciously, especially since it starts with a limited amount. They should bifurcate ESOPs into two categories: loyalty-based (10-15% of the pool) and performance-based. Functions like accounts or HR, which aren't sales-driven, could fall under loyalty, while roles like sales or tech could be performance-based. This ensures a balanced allocation across senior, mid, and junior levels, avoiding overallocation to senior staff. Additionally, founders should adhere to a standard vesting schedule (3-4 years) and set exercise prices low initially (e.g., Rs. 10) to attract talent and align incentives with company growth, pegging ESOPs to the latest round price or a discount. These strategies help founders effectively use ESOPs for company growth and employee retention.
In essence, effective ESOP management isn't just about numbers; it's about nurturing a culture where every team member sees themselves as a stakeholder in the company's journey. This approach not only enhances retention but also drives collective efforts towards achieving shared goals.
How do ESOPs impact a startup's financial statements and fundraising efforts? Are there any accounting complexities or dilution effects founders should be aware of?
ESOPs are charged to the P&L like any other expense, impacting profitability despite being a non-cash item. Unlike salaries that involve actual cash outflow, ESOPs affect financials by reducing profitability. Essentially, they represent a form of capital akin to investor contributions, reflecting their role in supporting long-term growth and employee retention strategies.
Don’t leave us yet!
MetaMorph isn't your typical HR firm. We're a 360° HR Advisory firm dedicated to helping startups scale, evolve, and grow. We’ve helped more than 220 startups and multiple hires (and counting), providing them with the platform and opportunities they deserve.
We look forward to bringing you more exciting initiatives aimed at building a stronger and more inclusive tech ecosystem. Stay tuned for future events and updates through our newsletter and by following us on social media.
Thank you for being a part of the MetaMorph journey!